Duck Tales: David McNab
ARTHUR:
In April of 1993, while still plotting their entry into the NHL, the Mighty Ducks of Anaheim announced that they had reached a contract agreement with New York Rangers scout David McNab. It was an interesting item, especially when you consider the fact that the Rangers allowed him to interview for the position on the condition that he would continue to work the 1993 Draft for them that summer. The Ducks were essentially saying, "we're hiring a new scout who, a few months from now after the Draft, will start working for us in some capacity." If that's news, then this guy must be good.
And he is. Appropriate for his 6'6" frame, McNab's scouting career is saturated with Bunyan-sized myths. He put 3,000 miles on a rental car in one weekend. He once drove from Minneapolis to Boston by himself in 26 hours. His travel on Northwest Airlines alone once tolled 1.5 million miles, and his 1978 Oldsmobile Cutlass topped out at 275,000.
That car, in particular, seemed to define McNab, who took to driving as a way to make money as a rookie scout. His first scouting job came under his father, former NHLer and then Washington Capitals GM Max McNab, and David was determined to work for free to prove himself. That left him with an expense account and reimbursements for mileage as his only source of income. But he used that to his advantage, employing his father's old-fashioned approach to the job. He drove long distances to see players, then he drove them to dinner afterwards. In a short drive and a quick meal, he got to know the wet-behind-the-ears versions of NHL greats like Chris Chelios, Mike Richter and Mike Modano. And they talked about everything, not just hockey.
It was on these thankless trips to faraway rinks that McNab made friends with fellow scout Jack Ferreira, who would rise through the NHL ranks and become the Mighty Ducks' first general manager. When Ferreira brought McNab to the Ducks in '93, he was no doubt hiring a friend, but he was also hiring an extremely talented résumé, which had the potential to climb the ranks and become Ducks general manager just as Ferreira had.
Though he was born in Vancouver, McNab actually lived in San Diego for some time while his father served as general manager of the Gulls. He played his youth hockey in Southern California from the sixth grade until he graduated from Point Loma High School in 1973. From there, he moved on to the University of Wisconsin, where he would serve as the backup goaltender for the 1977 championship team. His career as a player ended at that point, but he went to work for his father as a scout for the Capitals. To fight any appearance of nepotism, he refused a salary until his second year on the job, and when his father was fired in 1981, David left, too. He signed on with the Hartford Whalers, and he was promoted to Director of Player Recruitment in the last two years of his seven-year stint. He then spent four years with the Rangers and was named their Director of Player Personnel. When he came to the Ducks in 1993, the 35 year-old McNab already had 15 years of NHL scouting experience to match one of the most respected surnames in hockey.
His impact on Anaheim was immediate. Going into the 1994 Supplemental Draft, McNab was convinced he'd found a player from the University of Western Ontario. This was unlikely for two reasons. First, less than ten NHL players had emerged from the now-defunct Supplemental Draft. And second, it was extremely rare to find NHL talent in a Canadian college. In fact, there were only two scouting tapes available for this player, and when the Ontario coach called McNab to get them back, he claimed he'd lost them. He even issued a gag order on the scouting staff so that none of them would tip their hand before the Draft. And they didn't. The Panthers picked defenseman Sean McCann first, and the Ducks claimed center Steve Rucchin second. Rucchin would play ten years in Anaheim. He pivoted the dominant Kariya-Selanne line, and he was a key figure in all three of the team's pre-Lockout playoff appearances.
In his brief time as Director of Player Personnel, McNab oversaw the draft boards that brought key players like Pavel Trnka, Oleg Tverdosky, Mike Lecerlc, Ruslan Salei and Matt Cullen to the Ducks, and he was soon promoted for his efforts. When Pierre Gauthier moved on to Ottawa in 1995, the team named McNab his successor as Assistant GM. McNab would also take over as General Manager of the team's AHL affiliate, the Baltimore Bandits. And perhaps his greatest contribution to the Ducks was uprooting the team's minor squad from their dismal circumstances in Baltimore to a very successful setup in Ohio. The Cincinnati Mighty Ducks teams of the late 90s and early 2000s churned out some of the best talent in recent memory.
When the Ducks were sold in 2005, new GM Brian Burke extended offers to many of the team's legacy personnel, and McNab decided to stay, even if it meant a slight demotion. In the post-Lockout years, one of McNab's pet projects began to receive national attention. As the Ducks raced to the Stanley Cup, onlookers were shocked at how many members of their lineup were former NCAA undrafted free agents. Andy McDonald, Chris Kunitz, Dustin Penner, Ryan Shannon and Ryan Carter were all signed by McNab. And what's more, they were signed under the previous collective bargaining agreement, when the maximum contract was much higher and signing an undrafted free agent was a much bigger risk.
People certainly signed NCAA free agents before McNab, but they rarely got it as right as he did. There's a Bunyan-sized story of McNab rooting against Colgate and Andy McDonald in a playoff game with Michigan. Fearing the number of NHL scouts that were in the audience, McNab hoped against hope that McDonald would fall flat on his face and keep the Ducks from a bidding war. As it turns out, McNab had nothing to worry about. McDonald signed with Anaheim, and he even credited his decision to McNab's efforts. It was the the lunches, the level of attention, the fact that he could be playing in a rink in the middle of nowhere and look up into the stands and see McNab there that made him want to come to the Ducks. McDonald has gone on to a long and steady career, while the jewel of that year's NCAA free agent class, Steven Reinprecht, has had trouble sticking in a lineup.
Perhaps what's most impressive about McNab is that his dedication to promoting young talent goes beyond the players he is trying to scout and sign. In the early days of his career, he would use his position in Hartford to send baseball caps, media guides and handwritten letters to prospects he wanted to encourage. And at the end of an almost 20 year NHL career, goaltender Curtis Joseph personally thanked McNab for that encouragement. He pointed out that they had never met and McNab had no reason to give him so much attention, but without it, Joseph doubts he would have been willing to reach for his dream of being a professional hockey player.
After Brian Burke left, Bob Murray reinstalled McNab as Assistant General Manager and General Manager of the minor league squad, which put him back on the road for the Ducks GM job that Jack Ferreira started him on 17 years ago. McNab oversaw the end of the only Iowa CHOPS season, and he semi-successfully shuffled the Ducks prospects this year without an AHL franchise. But next season, he will be setting up the team's affiliate in Syracuse. He's already poaching the NCAA for two-way contracts as well as AHL-only contracts and is well on his way to recreating the Cincinnati days and building the Ducks of the future (which he will hopefully GM).
Despite the promotion, McNab almost left the Ducks last year after interviewing for the General Manager position in Minnesota. If he had gotten the job, it would have meant not only the departure of Anaheim's longest tenured employee but also a veritable sea change in the franchise's management. It was already hard to imagine what this team would look like without longtime goaltending coach François Allaire, but it's impossible to imagine a team without the infusion of McNab's young and well-developed talent. Every successful Ducks team has been stamped with their influence.
Whenever Bob Murray leaves-- and for whatever reason --if anyone but David McNab succeeds him, it will be the first true new era in Anaheim history.
Footnote Articles:
More of this was constructed from memory than I would like to admit, but I would recommend Rocking the Pond by Dean Chadwin as a great resource for first year Ducks history and the story of bringing McNab aboard. This article also utilizes some of the McNab profiles done by the LA Times below and, from memory, many of the McNab stories told by the LA Times staff. I wish I could track them all down.
This Job Leads McNab to The Ends Of The Earth by Robyn Norwood, July 1, 1995
McNab Goes Extra Mile for Good of The Ducks by Helene Elliott, May 13, 2006
2 recs |
26 comments
|
Comments
I know it’s long. But it’s a history segment. ‘Long’ means you’re learning. :-)
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 17, 2010 2:21 PM PDT reply actions
This is fantastic reading
and its really helpful for somone that knows nothing about the current FO. After reading this, I only have one question;
Why the hell is Bob Murray our GM?
by PhantomPretender on May 17, 2010 3:19 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
Actually, I haven’t been asking it. I know why.
Bob Murray was a career Blackhawk who basically skated off the ice and into the front office. They finally made him GM, and his two year run was a pretty big disaster culminating in Bob signing an aged Wendel Clark and having to buy him out. After he was fired, Murray eventually landed in Vancouver under Brian Burke’s regime.
When the Samuelis bought the Ducks, they installed Burke on reputation. Burke, in turn, brought in people he’d trusted from Vancouver, including Murph who was installed as Burke’s Assistant GM. Qualifications? None, really. Hindsight hasn’t lessened the disaster that was his time in Chicago and he spent all of his time afterward as a Pro Scout. In fact, when McNab was promoted to Assistant GM in 1995, he had a great foreshadowing quote:
“To be successful [as an assistant GM] you have to have scouted for a long time. You can’t just go from being a player in the NHL to a job like this.” – LA Times
And that’s why I say Bob Murray is a GM for the same reason that John Elway owns a car dealership. His qualifications are directly tied to his playing career and not to anything he’s really done since. He still hasn’t managed a playoff team (if you consider that Burke didn’t give up the reins until November of last season). I doubt the Samuelis know any better, as they’re still trusting Burke’s recommendation of Murph at this point and they had legal troubles to finish up this season. Who knows if they’ll promote McNab when Murph flames out? The real question is why McNab hasn’t gotten fed up and left working behind a buffoon like Murph and having Burke deal away so many of his NCAA free agents.
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 17, 2010 3:56 PM PDT up reply actions
oh, to be fair and balanced, Murph probably has a few more old boys club relationships around the league than McNab. I mean, Murph was able to call up his old defense partner, Doug Wilson, in San Jose and strike an uneven deal. That’s something McNab might not be able to do as easily, but resume versus resume, I would never EVER pick Murph to do ANYTHING in a front office. But that’s just me.
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 17, 2010 3:58 PM PDT up reply actions
Idk, I think we have the best of both worlds here. As you mentioned before, it’s highly doubtful that McNab would be able to pull off some of the deals that Murray has. I like the fact that Murray has some pull just because he knows people. On top of that, we’ve got McNab as Assistant as well. It seems like a win/win to me.
Just out of curiosity, how much authority does McNab actually have?
There's nothing to see here. And nothing gazes back at me.
Uhhh, I don’t know. I think you have to look at the actual deals. Murray dished Tangradi and Kunitz for Whitney. He shipped Eric O’Dell out to take a chance on Christensen. THAT’S the point, i.e. when he gave away prospects, that he had to call Wilson for a homeboy deal to get some lesser prospects in back. His work as the trigger man on deal day is spotty, friends or not. McNab, by contrast, is eerily spot on, even with guys from his past. Todd Marchant, for example, is the only NCAA player on the Rangers 1993 draft board. Hard to believe McNab didn’t have a say there. Murray brought in Huskins, whom he drafted in Chicago, McCarthy to camp (again, whom he drafted in Chicago) and Beauchemin as someone he scouted as a pro scout. Those three versus everything McNab has brought to the Ducks, even in a similar three year sample— meh.
If McNab leaves on the next GM opening, and he very likely could, we’re stuck with JUST Murray. Ask yourself how that sits with you, rather than this “best of both worlds” scenario. Plus, McNab is a legacy GM; his pops turned around the entire Capitals franchise. Don’t think he doesn’t have friends, too, beyond the ones he’s gained working in the Ducks front office.
As far as pull, it’s always hard to say. With the Ducks, assistant GM definitely manages the AHL team, so his authority is pretty total there, and usually handles a lot of the early talks on contract negotiations. Beyond that, it’s up to the GM.
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 17, 2010 4:26 PM PDT up reply actions
So I’m guessing if it were up to you, McNab would be GM and Murray would be bye-bye? I suppose I wouldn’t argue with that, considering what McNab has done for this franchise. As playing devil’s advocate here, if it’s such an obvious decision, why don’t the Samueli’s pull the trigger and send Murph home?
There's nothing to see here. And nothing gazes back at me.
Well, I think Murray has his hands on a lot of assets right now. That is the part that scares me. If our team was a great deal older with a shallow cupboard, he can’t really do anything wrong. But if you look at Murray and Burke’s record, especially with McNab’s free agents, they’ve shipped off a lot for very little. Sometimes it’s worked out; sometimes not. Will he give away another Curtis Glencross, Andy McDonald, Chris Kunitz? He certainly has the power to and the motivation to value his own draft picks and players over McNab’s assets.
As far as the Samuelis decision making, who can blame them? They don’t know anything about hockey. That’s why they hired Burke. Burke recommends Murray, and people all around the league say “great job, Murray,” then why make a change in their minds. If you look at a mistake like the Whitney trade, it takes a few years to really see how great Tangradi is. It’s like when the Stars gave away Iginla for Nieuwendyk. You really want to be able to hold up a Niewendyk and Stanley Cup when Iginla becomes that much of a star. What are the Ducks going to hold up? 3/4 of Visnovsky’s contract? For now, Murph is living off Burke’s recommendation and he’s treading water well. If no one pulls too hard on the curtain, his job is safe, and McNab moves on and wins Cups for some other team.
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 17, 2010 4:48 PM PDT up reply actions
GREAT READ! I try to tell as many people as possible that the reason the Ducks have been so successful is because of Francois Allaire and McNab. But I can’t get past the Ducks being successful even though they have been, much less explain that these guys were the glue that has kept them together. I was VERY sorry to see Allaire go and if they don’t wisen up and make McNab their front man I think the team will be in real big trouble.
Thanks for the article! Love this site.
You're very welcome
Allaire is a loss we won’t totally feel until the end of Hiller’s contract. From a scouting perspective, we now have to overdraft, as no one’s going to come here just to work with our goalie coach. So taking Bobkov and trading for Pielmeier were good ideas, but even if you look at teams like the Sharks that do a great job overdrafting netminders, they’re not always sure what they have when they let go of some of them (i.e. Kiprusoff versus Toskala). So, we’ll also need someone who evaluates talent as well as Allaire. That’s no offense to Peeters; Allaire is just hard to replace.
As far as McNab, I really can’t imagine this team without him. The franchise would survive of course, but it would be completely different, and there would definitely be a transition period. Good to know there are more McNab fans out there, though. This site will probably have to start a letter writing campaign if McNab leaves.
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 17, 2010 4:36 PM PDT up reply actions
Let’s do the letter writing campaign now!
The interesting thing is not just who he drafts/signs non-drafted free agents its also how they fit in! I mean look at Penner, AndyMac and Kunitz now? Though good contributors on their respective teams (Oilers, Blues, Penguins) they seemed to really fit in with the drafted Anaheim players. Obviously Penner with Getzy and Perry, Kunits with AndyMac and Selanne.
Not sure if he meant to do that or if it was a bit of Providence, but man those lines were awesome together. We haven’t quite seen them click like that again.
Haha. It might fall on deaf ears this close to the Visnovsky trade.
I think part of how well they fit in lies in how much time McNab spends with them one-on-one. He really gets a sense of these kids, and he signs smart players and hard workers who can adapt to systems. He always signs very coachable and playable guys. Mcdonald, for example, was able to put together an iron man streak after his first major injury.
There have definitely been some missteps when the system changes too drastically, though. Guys like Ryan Shannon and Curtis Glencross were really good forwards who finished their incubation when Burke and Carlyle took over. We probably ruined Shannon, and I still can’t explain why Burke dished Glencross. Curtis definitely seems mad about it every time he plays us, though. I guess I would be, too, because McNab probably gave him the hard sell, then Curtis put in a full AHL cycle only to get dished in the Cup year and have Joe Motzko gets his name on the Stanley Cup instead.
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 17, 2010 5:51 PM PDT up reply actions
Speaking of which, what ever happened to Motzko?
There's nothing to see here. And nothing gazes back at me.
I think he plays in Germany now. I liked Motzko in college; maybe McNab did, too. But we kind of put a lot of time into Glencross, who’s shown he can be a spare parts forward in the NHL and definitely had speed that we lacked for a while there. Just seems like we should have gotten more for him and Konopka.
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 17, 2010 6:04 PM PDT up reply actions
Ah the Rucchin Kariya Selanne line.....
Thanks for the trip down memory lane Arthur. That is my favorite line of all time for the Ducks. Wow were those guys great together.
McNab setting up Syracuse
Lindsay Kramer of the Crunch Blog talked to McNab yesterday about setting up in Syracuse.
by Arthur from Anaheim Calling on May 18, 2010 1:09 PM PDT reply actions
How clutch is that? If McNab sets up Syracuse and gets it running the way he wants we could have talent for years. That place could be the pinnacle of AHL teams sending talent to its NHL big brother.
by Newport Rebel on May 18, 2010 1:19 PM PDT up reply actions
so who goes to syracuse next year? clark, bonino (maybe our numba 1 center in the minors), deschamps, de gray, mitera, oystrick, holland, gardiner, schultz if they do leave wisconsin early we’ll have a stacked minor league team like the hershey bears!
Its too hard to say where Clark will go. With the FA market, seeing if Scotty comes back, and trades no one will know till pre season training. Our biggest question mark comes at the blueline and I don’t think anybody knows how that will shake out. Not even Bob Murray. I’m sure he knows what he wants to do but who knows if the other GM will go along with it. Bonino I think will spend next year bouncing up and down. As for your others, I think they will be in Syracuse.
by Newport Rebel on May 18, 2010 2:57 PM PDT up reply actions

by 










