Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Two Minutes Of Thunder Basketball Wins The Game

Now That You're Covering Anaheim, It's Time for Some Truthiness


Since Arthur started Anaheim Calling, the decision was made not to report on rumors. Everyone is welcome to speculate on the rumors in the comments, but you will never see them reported as fact here, at least until they are confirmed by the Ducks. A comment from an "unnamed NHL executive" isn't going to cut it as the truth. In fact, if one of our writers publishes false information, I have given myself permission to exile them to Eklund's website.

BUT...I have to make somewhat of an exception for this. Almost every single media outlet - including Canadian ones - are covering the possibility of Anaheim trading Bobby Ryan. That is as much as I am going to report on it because the Ducks did their best to dance around the issue with Eric Stephens this morning. My kibosh on rumors does not extend to personal observations, though. It starts with: we wouldn't be speculating/gossiping/fantasizing about this if the Ducks, and especially Bobby, were playing well. With one thing going wrong, should the foundation of the team be uprooted? Leadership comes from the top down, but that's just my opinion.

One thing that I noticed all day today is that for the first time, in a long time, the hockey media is intensely following Anaheim. Of course they are, this is a goldmine of a rumor and has "trade of the year" written all over it. The other thing I noticed in the media's reintroduction to Anaheim is that they are are getting some of their facts wrong. That is what's driving me crazy. Not the fact that I think it's a horrific idea trade Bobby Ryan and I am forced to check my phone every five seconds to see if the worst has come true, but the fact that they aren't even reporting correct information.

Star-divide

Fable #1 - Bobby is being dropped in the lineup and given less time as punishment.

For those of you that follow me on Twitter, you might have seen an exchange between myself and TSN's Scott Cullen on this story.

Screen_shot_2011-11-29_at_8

I responded after that with a snarky "this has been happening for three years" regarding Ryan being juggled in the lineup. If you read the story, he didn't change anything after that. It still looks like Ryan is being punished by being given less ice time and by being dropped to the third line. I don't want this to seem like I am a vigilante blogger going up against The Man, but c'mon, at least go back and add a note to your story.

As people that analyze everything Ducks, we know that at one time Matt Beleskey found success with the twins up front. That time has come, gone and is likely never coming back, but Randy Carlyle insists on giving it another try. I like Beleskey, just not very much on the top line anymore. He's a fourth line energy guy.

We preached this over and over last season - consistency breeds results. Saku Koivu and Teemu Selanne took time to get their chemistry back. Not once were they broken up to increase scoring chances. Keeping RPG together is going to continue to re-build their chemistry. Bobby is a notoriously streaky scorer and line juggling won't help. We don't have a third scoring line and seemingly never will. It probably has to do with the "Chris Pronger Curse" or something. The top two lines are going to have to carry the team until the Samueli's are ready to dish out some cash and invest in guys that are better than Ben Maxwell. (Who? Exactly.)

Fable #2 - Bobby is/was good and/or decent at center

Don't get me wrong, I adore Bobby, but dude was awful at center. For a guy that has so many natural talents taking faceoffs and covering all areas of the ice is not one of them. To end last season, Bobby had 87 faceoff wins and 132 faceoff losses for a lovely 39.7%. There is a reason that the great "Bobby at center" experiment ended about a quarter of the way into last season. He is a winger through and through. He needs to be either floating near the boards or parking his derriere in front of the net. Next they're going to be telling me that Andrew Cogliano is an All-Star center too. Makes sense since he was put on the left wing...say whaaa?

Fable #3 - Bobby is on the FIRST power play unit

This one isn't nearly as annoying as the other two. One cannot report that Bobby Ryan can't score on the power play when he's surrounded by his usual line mates. Anyone that has watched more than 10 minutes (ok, maybe 40 minutes) of a Ducks game will know he is replaced by Teemu Selanne on the power play's first unit. It is not at all appropriate to classify him as underachieving on the power play when the first unit usually does the damage before he steps on the ice.

As a Ducks fan, these passing weeks have been incredibly trying. Something has to give, but at what cost? There is a reason why Brian Burke took Bobby as his number two pick in the draft. I drank the Burkie Kool-Aid and believe that he's got a pretty good idea of what will make a player and a team successful. I'm sure he'd love to get his hands on Bobby now - which is all the more reason that the Ducks need to keep him. Oh and if I were Bob Murray, I'd be shopping Getzlaf. He's reached his peak and has nothing left to achieve.

Comment 9 comments  |  1 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

You had me until the last two sentences. The major problem with trying to trade Getzlaf is that your odds of getting the better player in the deal are slim and none. Getzlaf needs a kick in the ass and a different offensive strategy, not a ticket out of town.

by Ryanb903 on Nov 29, 2011 10:53 PM PST reply actions  

In some ways yes, in some ways no.

In the words of Layne Staley, Getzlaf is probably thinking, “what’s my motivation here?”. He honestly has nothing left to prove or achieve. The guy has won a Cup, scored a shit-ton in the playoffs, won a Gold Medal and two (I think) World Junior Championships. And on top of that, he’s the captain of his own hockey team. He honestly doesn’t need to prove anything else, but he should.

The other side of that argument is that he’s being paid the big bucks to help this team win games and reach that SCF again. For everyone in the organization, they depend on Ryan Getzlaf to perform. So yes, he can’t just quit like this.

This brings me to repeat the same question over and over again, do we need change? Options:

A) New coach.
If you heard Aaron Ward earlier in the night on TSN, you would realize that it is not fun playing hockey under Randy Carlyle. I’m sure Getzlaf feels, or has felt that same pain. Maybe he feels that pain right now and needs a new coach to motivate him. Hockey for Ryan Getzlaf just may not be fun under Randy Carlyle anymore.

B) Vacate his captaincy
This is a move made merely for the sake of allowing Getzlaf to achieve something else. He maybe needs the drive to re-gain the captaincy to ultimately motivate his game. He has everything now, so why not give him something to achieve again?

I’d say those are the only two options. Trading him isn’t one of them. You don’t trade a #1 centre of his calibre. They are maybe one of the hardest positions to come by. Ask the Calgary Flames. Under no circumstance do you try and shake this very good foundation.

"That might've been a little push, but that was a major flop. That would make Vlade Divac very proud." - Jerry Reynolds

by JuMowbray on Nov 29, 2011 11:26 PM PST via iPhone app up reply actions  

RIP Layne Staley

Great singer.

Contributor - Anaheim Calling

by light_the_lamp on Nov 30, 2011 3:07 PM PST up reply actions  

I actually completely agree with your last 2 sentences. As long as we get a heck of a lot in return, preferably an elite d-man.

by Ramsrnumerouno on Nov 29, 2011 11:24 PM PST reply actions  

Nailed it Jen. I don’t really believe the captaincy is putting pressure on Getz. I mean c’mon! Selanne is the face. The pressure if there is any in the Southern California market is on Selanne and what is he doing? The only reason why we are hearing Bobby instead of Getz is because Perry is going to stay and Carlyle “Doesn’t break up pairs.” Carlyle runs this organization. He knows if he keeps Selanne happy then he stays.. If Murray wants to keep his job.. Selanne needs to have a closed door meeting and let Carlyle go because if Getz or Ryan go where a top tier player is not returned.. Murray and Carlyle are gone.. And Scotty should replace Murray as GM and Selanne could be Assistant GM.. Put real leaders at the top of the organization

It’s the same thing with the Angels.. Scioscia runs the organization.. GMs have come and gone and the Angels still can’t make the playoffs.. Players dont really want to play for them and talent isn’t attracted by them.. Starting to be the same thing here

by ShamuSalami on Nov 29, 2011 11:38 PM PST via iPhone app reply actions  

Ducks need elite d-man,there´s absolutly no doubt about it,Beachemin is playin´mayor minutes,but in my eyes he´s not the first d-man of team,well he won´t be that guy in any team in this league.Second problem is Cam Fowler playin´offensive d-man,I know this guy is just teenage but come on,this is NHL,if he´s not ready let him play minor minutes and let him grow,he will be elite offensive d-man one day,but he´s not ready yet. Another question is: Is Randy Carlyle right coach for this team?Of course he won the first cup for us but team was different,they were playing total deffensive style and had some big names on the roster as Rob Niedermayer,Chris Pronger and one of the best deffensive forwards Rob Neidermayer nowadays roster seems to be more about offense and I don´t really know if Randy is right man for this type of play.

by SuperCass on Nov 30, 2011 12:59 AM PST reply actions  

I honestly think that having two all-star defensmen on our team covered up the fact that the system is defensively week. 2 top defensmen is not a luxury for Carlyle, it’s a necessity, and that is part of the problem in my mind.

by DavidBL on Nov 30, 2011 1:35 AM PST up reply actions  

Sorry about mistakes there should be Scott Niedermayer too:))

by SuperCass on Nov 30, 2011 1:12 AM PST reply actions  

but the fact that they aren’t even reporting correct information.

agreed…dont act like you know our team…
i know finiacial reasons are the reason carlye might not go….but dunno bite the bullet….the guys are tuning him out…..youll probally not get equal lue with a trade of any of the RPG line..why not at least try them with a new coach that might bring in system that might fit the RPG line and have a different voice…before u cut ties with these talented players…

Niles: You'll see who feels foolish when I'm sitting on a mechanical bull sipping champagne.
www.battleofcali.com

by SPADE-IN-VICTORHELL on Nov 30, 2011 5:18 AM PST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Anaheim calling to the hockey world...

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Dirty players?
Small
The Real Controversy
Small
Ducks Fail at NHL Draft Lottery; Will Still Pick 6th Overall
Jered-weaver_small
Mock Draft
Small
Random Crunch update
Jiraya_small
Weekend of Must
Small
OC Register's Jeff Miller is learning the value of magumbo
Selanne-kariya_small
Armchair GM: Deadline Wish List

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

CK Photo Galleries

Anaheim Calling

site stats


Coach Bombay

Image_small Jen Neale

Hans

Lincecum_basewars_small Arthur from Anaheim Calling

Ducks_small SK eleven

Flying V

Small Daniel AC

Tumblr_ljh6axc0sp1qftewzo1_500_small JuMowbray

Bloody-jersey_small PhantomPretender

Bobble_small Chris D-5

Selanne-kariya_small Kevin Riach

Small light_the_lamp

Bash Brothers

Hail_ants__small Floyd Gondoli

Small MoralesHomers