Concussions - Fantasy Impact
No I'm not that shallow. I know they're serious, and career threatening- never mind life changing. Some of the the players I looked up to when I was a kid had their careers end because of concussions. Namely Steve Young, and Paul Kariya. With all this talk about Crosby being out because of recurring symptoms and Colt McCoy being hit in the head and the subsequent suspension of Harrison because of it.... kinda made me wonder.
Then... watching my fantasy teams tank (in all 3 leagues i'm in) I decided to start overhauling my roster. And I saw this:
Milan Michalek - DTD, Concussion
Martin St. Lous- DTD (yeah right!), Facial Fractures (ouch!)
Mike Richards- IR, Concussion
Jeff Skinner- DTD, Concussion
Chris Pronger- IR, Concussion
Ryan Wilson- DTD, Concussion
Brayden Schenn- IR, Concussion
Matt D'Agostini- DTD, Concussion
Peter Mueller- IR, Head (aka concussion)
And that's just guys that are or were on my teams. Nevermind these guys:
Sidney Crosby- Concussion
Claude Giroux- Concussion
Kris Letang- Concussion
Zbynek Michalek - Concussion
The list goes on, and on, and on. And then add to that players like Ryan Miller, Andy McDonald, Marc Saverd, David Perron, James Reimer, Mark Staal, etc.
Is it me... or does it just seem like this is happening more often this year? And I'm not talking about just the Crosby affect where there's more media attention because of him, but just in general. Look at your fantasy teams. How many times have you had to drop guys from your roster, or put them on IR because of "Concussion." Thats how I notice it more. Not just because I'm in more leagues this year, but because a good chunk of the transactions are injury related, and even more specifically Concussion related.
This article was interesting, from SI.com: Concussions
And this from The Hockey Writers: Lingering
Ultimately, I believe it's the players responsibility. Take the Harrison hit on McCoy for example. In my opinion, Harrison clearly lead with the helmet. I understand it's hard to make split second decisions in sport, especially one as fast as hockey. Instinct and natural reaction kind of take over. In Harrison's case though- and I know this isn't hockey, but its the best example I can think of right now- he clearly, and purposefully lead with this helmet. Whether he aimed for McCoy's head or not, I can't tell. But I've seen many great tackles where responsible players lead with there shoulders. When you launch yourself like that at a player, whether you aim at their head or chest or crotch for that matter- its irresponsible. The Tootoo (I hate him!) hit on Miller is a somewhat similar example, though it didn't result in an injury. You have to make an effort to not injure a player. If you play the game to hurt people, like Harrison, you shouldn't be allowed to play.
What do you guys think? Media attention, or more frequent? How is it affecting your fantasy teams - let's assume all players will be forever healthy, and have great careers- get the 'human side' out of this equation for arguments sake.
This article is user-generated. It does not necessarily reflect the views of Anaheim Calling. Please do not link this article as representative of Anaheim Calling content or viewpoints . . . unless it's really really good.
2 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
2 Things on that
1) I really would like to see an additional IR slot added to the rosters in the H2H Keeper league for this reason
2) It s interesting to see that the league has not acted since the good old Teemu / Paul days (third video in the Teemu tribute post today focuses on exactly that: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=OGzmhMp5PUM). I really, REALLY do not understand why some people claim that Shanahan is “destroying the game” or “taking physicality away from the sport”. He is protecting people from assaults. That’s all. This is not a death match, it’s hockey. And everyone loves clean hits, but something is wrong if some of the world’s best players are out with concussions at the same time…
Well part of it is the NHL rules on the issue.
In years past, players would play no matter what. Now the NHL is sitting them down and making sure everything is ok before sending them out there again.

by 
















